New research shows increased camouflage mismatch in mountain hares due to climate change

“The camouflage mismatch of mountain hares is really surprising and worrying, and suggest that some wild animals can’t adapt quick enough to match the rate of climate change”

Mountain hares in Scotland show increasing camouflage mismatch due to less snowy winters, according to a new study carried out by an international research team including the James Hutton Institute.

Mountain hares are one of multiple species that moult from a dark coat in summer to a white coat in winter to maintain camouflage against snowy landscapes. But due to climate change, the duration of snow cover is decreasing—creating a “mismatch” in seasonal camouflage that exposes the hares to predators.

Marketa Zimova, an evolutionary ecologist at the University of Michigan’s Institute for Global Change Biology and lead author of the study, explains that the observed lack of change in the timing of important life events, or “phenological shift”- an organism’s ability to adapt the timing of their life events such as moults to changing environmental conditions - can endanger a species’ survival.

Zimova explains: “Our research on the snowshoe hares in Montana, another colour moulting species, showed that camouflage mismatched hares suffer much higher predation rates. We also found that the increase in mortality due to mismatch will, in the absence of an adaptive shift, lead to population declines by 2100.”

Key to the mountain hare study were published historical datasets by Adam Watson and John Flux that describe the seasonal moult of wild mountain hares in the Scottish Highlands during the 1950s and 1960s. The research team note that according to their best knowledge, these earlier studies represent the longest running systematic historical survey of moult phenology in any species.

The team returned to the Scottish Highlands to carry out surveys and record the pattern and timing of moult over multiple spring and fall seasons. This allowed comparisons between present and historical timing of the colour moults. Further, by employing statistical analysis, the researchers calculated the change in temperature and snow cover over the past 65 years within the study region.

Despite the dramatic change in climate, there was little evidence of an adaptive shift in moult phenology in Scotland’s mountain hares - resulting in a mean of 35 more days a year when white hares are found on dark, snowless background since the 1950s.

Scott Newey, an animal ecologist at the James Hutton Institute and co-author of the study, said: “The camouflage mismatch of mountain hares is really surprising and worrying, and suggests that some wild animals can’t adapt quick enough to match the rate of climate change.”

These concerns are shared by L. Scott Mills, a professor at the University of Montana and a fellow co-author of the study. He added: “These are important findings because they indicate that some colour moulting species are not responding as we’d expect based on what we’ve seen in other systems.”

The reason that the mountain hare moult phenology has remained relatively static is not clear, but Zimova hypothesizes that the reason might be due to the reduction in the number and diversity of predators associated with land management in large parts of the study area.

Sean Giery, an Eberly fellow from the Pennsylvania State University and also a co-author of the study, commented: “It’s an interesting scenario playing out in the Highlands. We saw this really distinct increase in camouflage mismatch that didn’t conform to findings in other ecosystems like Montana.

“It took us a while to realize that what we were seeing – steadily increasing camouflage mismatch in mountain hares - might be the result of an ecosystem subject to climate change, and a history of predator control. Without many predators, fitness costs of camouflage mismatch might be minimal."

Zimova notes that recent climate change has already subjected wild populations to large change in environmental conditions, and failure of a species to adapt to these changes will ultimately result in decline and extinction.

“If we want species to persist in a rapidly changing world, we need to understand their responses to climate change. This challenge includes considering a suite of anthropogenic changes, and how they interact,” she added.

Paper: Zimova Marketa, Giery Sean T., Newey Scott, Nowak J. Joshua, Spencer Michael and Mills L. Scott (2020). Lack of phenological shift leads to increased camouflage mismatch in mountain hares. Proc. R. Soc. B,.28720201786, http://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2020.1786.